The Kansas City Chiefs have made waves in the NFL offseason with a surprising decision at the left tackle position, a critical role in protecting quarterback Patrick Mahomes’ blindside. After a challenging 2024 season plagued by inconsistency at left tackle, the Chiefs invested heavily to address the issue, signing veteran offensive tackle Jaylon Moore to a two-year, $30 million contract with $21.24 million fully guaranteed. However, in a stunning twist, the team has opted to name rookie Josh Simmons, selected 32nd overall in the 2025 NFL Draft, as the starting left tackle for the 2025 season, relegating Moore to a backup role.
A Bold Move in Free Agency
Coming off a disappointing 2024 campaign where the Chiefs struggled to solidify their offensive line, general manager Brett Veach moved quickly to bolster the unit. The signing of Jaylon Moore, formerly of the San Francisco 49ers, was seen as a significant step toward stabilizing the left tackle position. Moore, who served primarily as a backup during his four seasons with the 49ers, showed promise in limited action. In 2024, he played 271 snaps, allowing just one sack, two quarterback hits, seven hurries, and 10 total pressures, according to Pro Football Focus (PFF). His performance earned him a pass-blocking grade of 73.1, a run-blocking grade of 70.1, and an overall grade of 74.9—solid numbers that justified the Chiefs’ investment.
The two-year, $30 million deal was a clear signal that Kansas City viewed Moore as a potential solution to their ongoing left tackle woes. Fans and analysts alike expected Moore to step into the starting role, providing veteran stability to a line that had been a weak point in protecting Mahomes. However, recent developments have turned those expectations upside down.
The Rise of Josh Simmons
In a surprising turn of events, the Chiefs have decided to entrust the starting left tackle role to Josh Simmons, their first-round pick out of Ohio State. Selected 32nd overall in the 2025 NFL Draft, Simmons was initially projected to develop behind a veteran like Moore, potentially taking over as the starter in 2026. However, reports from ESPN’s Adam Teicher indicate that the Chiefs are ready to throw Simmons into the fire from Week 1 of the 2025 season, provided his recovery from a knee injury progresses as expected.
Teicher, speaking on SportsRadio810, stated, “If Josh Simmons is ready to go, he will be the Chiefs’ starting left tackle to begin the season. Right now, Jaylon Moore is viewed as Plan B, but it’s all dependent on Simmons’ knee.” This revelation has sent shockwaves through Chiefs Kingdom, as many assumed Moore’s hefty contract signaled a guaranteed starting role.
Simmons, a highly touted prospect, brings athleticism and upside to the position. His college tape at Ohio State showcased a combination of agility, strength, and technical prowess, making him a natural fit for Andy Reid’s offense. However, his readiness to handle the demands of protecting Mahomes against elite NFL pass rushers remains a question mark, especially given his ongoing recovery. The Chiefs’ decision to prioritize Simmons over Moore reflects their confidence in the rookie’s potential to become a cornerstone of the offensive line for years to come.
Moore as Plan B
The decision to designate Jaylon Moore as the backup is particularly surprising given the financial commitment the Chiefs made to him. A two-year, $30 million contract is not typically the price tag for a reserve player, leading to speculation about the team’s long-term strategy. Moore’s experience and solid performance metrics make him a valuable insurance policy should Simmons struggle or face setbacks in his recovery. Over four seasons with the 49ers, Moore played 826 snaps, allowing five sacks, eight quarterback hits, 18 hurries, and 31 total pressures, demonstrating reliability in pass protection.
The move also highlights the Chiefs’ willingness to take risks in pursuit of a third consecutive Super Bowl title. By investing in both a proven veteran and a high-upside rookie, Kansas City has created flexibility at a critical position. If Simmons falters, Moore can step in without a significant drop-off in performance. Conversely, if Simmons excels, the Chiefs may have found their left tackle of the future, with Moore providing mentorship and depth.
Addressing a Persistent Problem
The Chiefs’ left tackle position has been a revolving door in recent years. In 2024, neither rookie Kingsley Suamataia nor second-year player Wanya Morris emerged as a reliable starter. Suamataia, a second-round pick, struggled with a 36.8 overall PFF grade and allowed 13 pressures in just 162 snaps. Morris, meanwhile, posted a 54.0 pass-blocking grade, underscoring the need for an upgrade. The midseason signing of veteran D.J. Humphries provided a temporary boost, but his limited availability and lack of long-term commitment prompted the Chiefs to pursue Moore and draft Simmons.
Head coach Andy Reid has emphasized the importance of finding a long-term solution at left tackle, stating, “Eventually, you want to get someone in there who does a good job and can stay in there and be that guy.” The decision to start Simmons suggests that Reid and the coaching staff believe the rookie has the potential to be “that guy,” while Moore’s presence ensures the team isn’t left scrambling if the experiment fails.
What’s Next for the Chiefs?
The Chiefs’ bold decision to prioritize Simmons over Moore sets the stage for an intriguing 2025 season. With Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce leading the offense, Kansas City remains a Super Bowl contender, but the success of their offensive line will be critical to their aspirations. Simmons’ development will be closely watched, as his ability to protect Mahomes could determine whether the Chiefs can maintain their dominance in the AFC.
Meanwhile, Moore’s role as a high-priced backup raises questions about the Chiefs’ salary cap management. With other key free agents like Trey Smith and Nick Bolton requiring new contracts, general manager Brett Veach will need to navigate a tight cap situation to keep the roster intact. Moore’s contract, while expensive for a reserve, provides security and flexibility, allowing the Chiefs to weather potential injuries or growing pains with Simmons.
As training camp approaches, all eyes will be on Josh Simmons and his recovery from injury. If he can live up to his first-round billing, the Chiefs may have solved their left tackle problem for the foreseeable future. If not, Jaylon Moore stands ready to step in, ensuring that Kansas City’s offensive line remains a strength rather than a liability.