In a stunning development, the Buffalo Bills are reportedly considering cutting one of quarterback Josh Allen’s primary weapons, according to a controversial report from Athlon Sports. The focus of this news is tight end Dalton Kincaid, who has become a reliable target in the Bills’ offensive system since being selected in the first round of the 2023 NFL Draft. If this decision comes to fruition, it could shake not only the Bills’ roster but also their fanbase, which has high expectations for a successful season led by Allen—the 2024 NFL MVP.
Dalton Kincaid’s Journey with Buffalo
Dalton Kincaid, with his smooth route-running and sure hands, quickly established himself as a key component of the Bills’ offense. In the 2024 season, he recorded 44 receptions for 448 yards and 2 touchdowns in 13 games, despite battling a serious knee injury, including a torn PCL in one knee and fluid buildup in the other. While his stats didn’t quite meet the lofty expectations, Kincaid remained a vital piece in critical situations, particularly in the red zone and on short-yardage passing plays.
The on-field chemistry between Kincaid and Josh Allen was built on trust and synergy. Allen has praised Kincaid’s intelligence and instincts, calling him “a smart teammate who never buckles under big moments.” Plays like a 29-yard reception against the Pittsburgh Steelers or a 22-yard touchdown against the Denver Broncos showcased the potential of this duo.
Reasons Behind the Shocking Decision
The Athlon Sports report suggests that the consideration to cut Kincaid may stem from several factors, including financial pressures from the salary cap and the team’s roster restructuring strategy. With Josh Allen’s massive 6-year, $330 million contract, the Bills are looking to balance their budget to maintain strength at other positions. Additionally, the presence of veteran tight end Dawson Knox, who remains highly valued by head coach Sean McDermott for his consistency and Allen’s trust, may render Kincaid “expendable” in the eyes of the front office.
Another factor is Kincaid’s inconsistent performance in high-stakes moments. In the Bills’ AFC Championship Game loss to the Kansas City Chiefs in 2024, a dropped pass on a crucial fourth-down play drew heavy criticism from fans and media. Although teammates, including Allen and Knox, defended him, asserting that one play doesn’t define his value, the incident may have shaken the coaching staff’s confidence in his ability to handle pressure.
Reactions from Fans and Analysts
This potential decision immediately sparked a firestorm of debate among Bills Mafia. Many fans argue that cutting a young talent like Kincaid, who still has significant upside, is a risky move that could weaken the Bills’ offense, which already faces depth issues at the receiver position. On platforms like X, fans expressed frustration, with some suggesting the Bills should focus on bolstering their defense instead of “sacrificing” one of Allen’s key weapons.
Analysts are also divided. Some, like Yahoo!’s Frank Schwab, believe Kincaid remains an essential part of the Bills’ long-term strategy, especially given his synergy with stars like Khalil Shakir and Amari Cooper. Others argue that with the emergence of rookies like Keon Coleman and Knox’s reliability, the Bills might be willing to take a gamble to prioritize other positions.
The Future of the Bills and Josh Allen
If the Bills proceed with cutting Kincaid, it would mark one of the boldest moves by GM Brandon Beane in recent years. Josh Allen, at the peak of his career and a clear team leader, will likely have a say in the matter. In the past, Allen has been vocal in supporting close teammates, and losing Kincaid could impact his confidence in critical situations.
On the other hand, if Kincaid stays, the Bills must find ways to improve his consistency, particularly after injuries hampered his 2024 performance. A clear development plan, coupled with maximizing the Kincaid-Knox tandem, could help the Bills maintain their status as one of the AFC’s top teams.
Conclusion
The reported decision to cut Dalton Kincaid, though unconfirmed, has raised significant questions about the Buffalo Bills’ strategy for the upcoming season. With Josh Allen at the height of his powers and a talented roster, the Bills stand at a critical juncture: continue to invest in young talents like Kincaid or make bold changes to pursue a Super Bowl. Whatever the outcome, this story is sure to remain a focal point for media and fans in the weeks ahead.