Skip to main content

A shocking trade idea is being proposed for the Dallas Cowboys, but would they actually consider it?

Posted on May 17, 2025 - 2:01 am by

Brother of Dallas Cowboys superstar floats exciting tight end trade idea

They’re one year late based on their proclamation, but Jerry Jones and the Dallas Cowboys appear to be “all-in” this offseason.

They didn’t make any huge moves during NFL free agency, but they were far more active than they were in 2024. That was true beyond outside signings, as the Cowboys brought in two former first-round picks via trade: cornerback Kaiir Elam and linebacker Kenneth Murray.

Dallas also retained Osa Odighizuwa on a contract that proved to be a steal. Throw in their great draft haul and the addition of George Pickens after the draft, and this has been a good offseason for the Cowboys. But Terrance Parsons Jr. thinks they could make it even better.

Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts prepares for a game against the New York Giants at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. / Brett Davis-Imagn Images

Parsons, who is the brother of superstar pass rusher Micah Parsons, floated the idea of adding Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts, who has yet to reach his potential but is still just 24 years old.

 

The Proposal: Kyle Pitts to Dallas

Kyle Pitts, selected fourth overall by the Falcons in the 2021 NFL Draft, was once heralded as a generational talent at tight end. With his rare combination of size (6’6″, 246 lbs), speed, and athleticism, Pitts was expected to redefine the position. In his rookie season, he showed flashes of brilliance, recording 1,026 receiving yards—a rare feat yards—a rare feat for a tight end. However, his production has since declined due to inconsistent quarterback play and coaching changes in Atlanta, with only 1,305 yards over the next three seasons combined. Now entering a contract year in 2025, Pitts remains a tantalizing “what-if” player who could thrive in the right system.

Terrance Parsons Jr. believes Pitts could be the missing piece for the Cowboys’ offense. In a recent statement, he floated the idea of Dallas acquiring Pitts to pair with their already talented roster, including quarterback Dak Prescott, wide receivers CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens, and tight end Jake Ferguson. The Cowboys’ passing game, already poised for a strong 2025, could become even more dynamic with Pitts as a mismatch weapon capable of stretching defenses.

Why It’s Exciting

The idea of adding Kyle Pitts is undeniably thrilling for Cowboys fans. Dallas has prioritized offensive firepower this offseason, with the Pickens trade addressing a critical need at wide receiver. Pitts could elevate their passing attack to elite status. His ability to line up both inline and out wide would give offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer endless possibilities in play design. Paired with Lamb’s route-running precision and Pickens’ deep-threat ability, Pitts could exploit single coverage from linebackers or safeties, creating a nightmare for opposing defensive coordinators.

Moreover, Pitts’ youth aligns with the Cowboys’ core. At 24, he’s in the same age bracket as players like Micah Parsons (25), Jake Ferguson (26), and DaRon Bland (25), offering long-term upside if Dallas can unlock his potential. With Prescott coming off a 2024 season hampered by injury but still showing elite arm talent, a healthy 2025 campaign could see him distributing the ball to a trio of pass-catchers capable of All-Pro production.

The Case Against the Trade

Despite the excitement, there are significant hurdles to making this trade a reality. The Cowboys already have a capable tight end in Jake Ferguson, who emerged as a reliable target in 2024 with 43 receptions for 498 yards and 3 touchdowns, despite playing behind a depleted offensive line. Ferguson, also in a contract year in 2025, has earned Prescott’s trust and provides blocking versatility that Pitts, known more for his receiving, doesn’t match. Additionally, second-year tight end Luke Schoonmaker, a 2023 second-round pick, is still developing and could factor into Dallas’ plans.

Financially, the trade poses challenges. Pitts is in the final year of his rookie deal, with a 2025 cap hit of approximately $10.5 million. If acquired, Dallas would likely need to extend him, with top tight ends commanding contracts in the $15–$17 million per year range. The Cowboys’ salary cap is already strained, with looming extensions for Micah Parsons (projected at $35–$40 million annually) and CeeDee Lamb’s recent deal averaging $34 million per year. Adding Pitts’ long-term cost could force Dallas to make tough roster decisions, especially with Ferguson and other veterans like cornerback DaRon Bland also due for new contracts.

Logistically, the Falcons have shown little interest in trading Pitts. Atlanta’s front office views him as a cornerstone of their offense, particularly with quarterback Kirk Cousins under contract through 2026. Any trade would likely require a steep price—potentially a first- or second-round draft pick, plus additional assets—given Pitts’ pedigree and potential. For a Cowboys team that just traded a 2026 third-round pick and a 2027 fifth-rounder for Pickens, parting with more draft capital could deplete their ability to address other needs, such as defensive tackle or offensive line depth.

Would the Cowboys Consider It?

The Cowboys’ front office, led by owner Jerry Jones and COO Stephen Jones, has shown a willingness to take bold swings this offseason. The Pickens trade, described as one of Dallas’ most aggressive moves in years, suggests they’re not content with standing pat. Stephen Jones hinted at further roster tweaks, stating, “We’re still open to looking at an explosive number two that could upgrade us,” though this was in reference to the receiver position pre-Pickens. The question is whether they’d view Pitts as a luxury or a necessity.

On one hand, Dallas’ “all-in” mentality for 2025—evident in their draft haul and Pickens acquisition—could make them open to a splash like Pitts. Jerry Jones has never shied away from headline-grabbing moves, and a Prescott-Lamb-Pickens-Pitts quartet would generate buzz and ticket sales while giving Dallas a legitimate shot at the NFC East crown against rivals like the Philadelphia Eagles and Washington Commanders.

On the other hand, practical considerations weigh heavily. The Cowboys’ defense, while anchored by Parsons, needs reinforcements, particularly in the run game after Mazi Smith’s underwhelming development. A proposed trade for a run-stuffing defensive tackle like DJ Reader has also surfaced, which might take precedence over an offensive luxury like Pitts. Moreover, Ferguson’s emergence reduces the urgency to invest heavily at tight end, especially when Pitts’ production hasn’t matched his draft hype. As one source noted, the price for Pitts “would be too steep for a team that already has Jake Ferguson and Luke Schoonmaker.”

The Verdict

The idea of Kyle Pitts joining the Dallas Cowboys is a tantalizing one, sparking visions of an offensive juggernaut that could dominate the NFC. Terrance Parsons Jr.’s proposal has ignited fan excitement, and for good reason—Pitts’ skill set could complement an already stacked roster. However, the combination of financial constraints, existing talent at tight end, and Atlanta’s reluctance to deal makes this trade a long shot. The Cowboys are more likely to prioritize defensive upgrades or depth pieces over a high-risk, high-reward move like Pitts.

While Jerry Jones loves a bold headline, the Cowboys’ front office has shown a calculated side this offseason, balancing splashy moves with long-term roster building. Unless the Falcons unexpectedly lower their asking price or Pitts demands a trade, this idea may remain just that—an exciting but unrealistic dream for Cowboys Nation.