The NFL’s newly introduced Protector of the Year Award honors the league’s top offensive lineman, recognizing their critical role in protecting the quarterback and driving the offense. For the Kansas City Chiefs, coming off a 40-22 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LIX, two surprising candidates—Creed Humphrey and Trey Smith—could emerge as contenders for this prestigious award in the 2025 season. Despite the Chiefs’ struggles against the Eagles’ “Tush Push” and dominant defense, Humphrey and Smith showcased skills that make them ideal fits for this accolade.
Creed Humphrey: The Anchor at Center
Creed Humphrey, a 2021 second-round pick, has established himself as one of the NFL’s premier centers. His consistency, strength, and football IQ were evident even in the Chiefs’ Super Bowl loss, where he held the line against Philadelphia’s aggressive front. Humphrey’s ability to read defenses and make pre-snap adjustments is crucial for protecting Patrick Mahomes, who relies on time to extend plays. With over 1,000 snaps in the 2024 season, Humphrey’s durability and versatility in pass protection and run blocking make him a strong candidate. His role will be vital as the Chiefs aim to bolster their run game following Isiah Pacheco’s injury and Kareem Hunt’s return.
Trey Smith: The Rising Star at Guard
Trey Smith, a 2021 sixth-round pick, has emerged as a key piece of Kansas City’s offensive line. Despite the Eagles’ “Tush Push” overwhelming the Chiefs in Super Bowl LIX, Smith’s physicality and competitive mindset shone through. He expressed admiration for the play, stating, “You can’t really punish the team for being great at something they do.” Smith’s growth in pass protection and ability to handle elite edge rushers make him a dark horse for the award. His performance against Philadelphia’s All-Pro defenders highlights his potential to compete for the Protector of the Year.
Why These Two Stand Out
Andy Reid’s philosophy of building from the trenches has kept the Chiefs’ offensive line among the league’s best, even after trading All-Pro Joe Thuney. Humphrey and Smith’s complementary skills—Humphrey’s cerebral leadership and Smith’s physical dominance—position them as ideal candidates. Their ability to protect Mahomes, who faced six sacks in Super Bowl LIX, will be critical in 2025. Both players are expected to play key roles in countering physical defenses like the Eagles’, led by Vic Fangio, as the Chiefs chase redemption.
Looking Ahead to the 2025 Season
With Reid signed through 2029 and Mahomes in his prime, the Chiefs remain contenders, but their success depends on the offensive line. The NFL’s decision to delay the “Tush Push” ban until May means Humphrey and Smith will face similar challenges next season. Their ability to protect Mahomes and open running lanes will determine Kansas City’s fate. As the Protector of the Year Award highlights the importance of offensive linemen, Humphrey and Smith have a chance to shine and cement their legacies.
Conclusion
Creed Humphrey and Trey Smith are surprising yet deserving candidates for the NFL’s Protector of the Year Award. Their contributions in the trenches, often overshadowed by Mahomes and Reid, are vital to the Chiefs’ success. As Kansas City looks to rebound from their Super Bowl loss, Humphrey and Smith’s performances will be under the spotlight, potentially earning them recognition as the league’s top offensive lineman.