The New England Patriots’ 2025 NFL Draft brought plenty of highlights, but not all were met with universal praise. Among the most intriguing storylines, the drama surrounding the decision to select running back TreVeyon Henderson in the second round (No. 38 overall) has taken center stage. Reports indicate that the Patriots initially targeted a different player, only to pivot to Henderson, sparking speculation about internal disagreements over draft strategy among team leadership and coaching staff. So, what really happened in the Patriots’ war room? Let’s dive in.
Context: An Ambitious Draft
The Patriots entered the 2025 NFL Draft with a clear goal: build a roster around their young quarterback, Drake Maye. After selecting LSU left tackle Will Campbell in the first round (No. 4 overall), the team continued to prioritize the offense, aiming to provide maximum support for Maye. The selection of Henderson, a dynamic running back from Ohio State, was seen as a move to add explosiveness to the offense. With a 4.43-second 40-yard dash, impressive receiving skills (27 receptions, 284 yards in 2024), and strong pass-protection abilities, Henderson was expected to be a versatile weapon.
However, the decision was not without controversy. Many analysts questioned the need for a running back in the second round, especially since the Patriots had recently extended Rhamondre Stevenson’s contract and had Antonio Gibson on the roster. Opting for Henderson over a wide receiver or cornerback—positions considered more pressing—ignited debate. But what made the story even more compelling was the revelation of a heated internal dispute within the Patriots’ organization before Henderson’s name was called.
The Internal Drama: Who Made the Call?
According to Eliot Wolf, the Patriots’ Director of Player Personnel, the team’s war room experienced a “lively discussion” before finalizing their pick at No. 38. Wolf admitted that another player was initially targeted, but that player was selected by another team between picks 33 and 37. This forced the Patriots to pivot to Henderson. While Wolf declined to name the mystery player, this revelation was enough to fuel speculation about internal discord.
The key figures in the discussion included head coach Mike Vrabel, Vice President of Player Personnel Ryan Cowden, Director of Scouting Matt Groh, and scouting advisor Alonzo Highsmith. Wolf described the debate as “a step in the right direction” for building an effective working relationship, emphasizing that “constructive disagreements” are necessary for making the best decisions. However, his description left fans wondering: Was this truly a constructive discussion, or a heated clash over the team’s direction?
The story became even more intriguing when Henderson himself admitted he was surprised to be picked by the Patriots. In a post-draft press conference, he revealed that he had only one Zoom meeting with running backs coach Tony Dews prior to the draft, with no in-person meetings at the NFL Combine or his Pro Day. “Honestly, I didn’t think New England would be my destination. I was genuinely shocked when I got the call,” Henderson shared. The apparent lack of pre-draft connection between the Patriots and Henderson further fueled speculation that he may not have been the team’s first choice.
Unanswered Questions
This drama raises several questions that fans and analysts are eager to have answered:
Who was the mystery player? Based on mock drafts and the picks between 33 and 37, potential candidates could include wide receiver Luther Burden II, tight end Mason Taylor, or a cornerback like Jahdae Barron. If the Patriots were targeting a wide receiver, it suggests that some in the front office prioritized that position over running back. Missing out on their preferred player may have forced them to “settle” for Henderson, despite his elite talent. Who had the final say? With key figures like Vrabel, Wolf, and Groh involved, it’s unclear who ultimately made the call. Vrabel, as head coach, may have favored a player who fit his hard-nosed playing style. Meanwhile, Wolf, responsible for personnel decisions, might have leaned toward a longer-term strategy. This difference in philosophy could have been the root of the disagreement. Will the conflict linger? Although Wolf emphasized that the debate was “constructive,” such disagreements could have lasting consequences. If the front office and coaching staff continue to clash over draft strategy or player usage, it could impact team cohesion in the 2025 season.
Impact and Future Implications
Despite the controversy, the selection of Henderson holds significant potential. Analysts have praised his explosiveness, comparing him to running backs like Breece Hall or Jahmyr Gibbs. With the return of offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels, known for utilizing versatile running backs in passing situations, Henderson could become a dangerous weapon. However, the overlap with Stevenson and Gibson poses challenges for the coaching staff in managing playing time.
This internal drama also sets the stage for compelling storylines in the future. If Henderson shines, the war room debate will be remembered as a mere anecdote. But if he underperforms, or if the Patriots struggle at positions like wide receiver, the disagreement could resurface. Furthermore, the presence of Vrabel and Wolf in their new leadership roles has fans curious about how they will reshape the Patriots post-Bill Belichick.
Conclusion
The selection of TreVeyon Henderson in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft was more than just a tactical decision—it was a drama-filled saga of internal conflict within the New England Patriots. From the heated debate in the war room to Henderson’s own surprise at being chosen, the episode sheds light on the challenges of aligning visions among team leadership. Whether the outcome proves triumphant or turbulent, this drama will undoubtedly remain a hot topic throughout the 2025 season, as fans wait to see if the Patriots can turn their disagreements into a recipe for a successful new era.