Is Will Grier the Answer for QB2 in Dallas This Season?
The Dallas Cowboys enter the 2024 season with a settled QB1 in Dak Prescott, but uncertainty lingers over who will secure the backup role. Veteran quarterback Will Grier, who joined the team in 2023, has emerged as a candidate for the QB2 job—but is he the right choice?
Grier, a 2019 third-round pick by the Carolina Panthers, has struggled to cement himself in the NFL. Across stints with the Panthers and Cowboys, he’s thrown just 61 regular-season passes, completing 53% for 523 yards, four touchdowns, and four interceptions. His limited in-game experience raises questions about his readiness to step in for Prescott if needed. However, Grier has flashed potential in preseason action, including a standout 2023 performance against the Las Vegas Raiders where he threw for 305 yards and two touchdowns.
The Cowboys’ QB2 competition likely pits Grier against Cooper Rush, Prescott’s longtime backup. Rush has proven capable in spot starts, most notably guiding Dallas to a 4-1 record during Prescott’s 2022 injury absence. His familiarity with the system and calm under pressure give him an edge in reliability. Meanwhile, Grier offers more mobility and a stronger arm, traits that align with offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer’s scheme.
Head coach Mike McCarthy has praised Grier’s growth, stating, “Will’s taken massive strides in understanding our offense. His athleticism and downfield vision are assets.” Still, the Cowboys reportedly explored adding a veteran QB this offseason, signaling some hesitation about their in-house options.
Ultimately, Grier’s preseason performances will determine his fate. If he replicates his 2023 preseason efficiency and outduels Rush in training camp, the job could be his. But with Dallas eyeing a Super Bowl run, trusting an unproven backup carries risk.
Verdict: NO
While Grier has shown flashes, Cooper Rush’s experience and proven track record in critical moments make him the safer choice for QB2. Dallas is unlikely to gamble on potential over reliability in a championship-or-bust season.