The Dallas Cowboys are gearing up for an intriguing battle at the left tackle position as the 2025 NFL season approaches, with Asim Richards and Tyler Guyton emerging as the primary contenders to anchor the team’s offensive line. The outcome of this competition could send shockwaves through the NFL, potentially reshaping the Cowboys’ offensive strategy with an unexpected starter.
Tyler Guyton, a first-round pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, was initially seen as the heir apparent to the left tackle role. His size, athleticism, and raw potential made him a cornerstone of Dallas’ future plans. However, his rookie season was marked by inconsistency, raising questions about his readiness to take on such a critical position. Posts on X have reflected mixed sentiments, with some fans urging the Cowboys to give Guyton every chance to prove himself, while others suggest he may need more time to develop or even serve as a swing tackle if he struggles early in the season.
Enter Asim Richards, a lesser-known name who could be the dark horse in this race. A sixth-round pick in 2023, Richards has quietly impressed coaches with his versatility and growth. His ability to play multiple positions along the offensive line has earned him praise, with some analysts, including former Cowboys great Nate Newton, naming him a potential surprise starter at left tackle. Richards’ development has been a topic of discussion, with observers noting his potential to outperform expectations and secure a starting role.
The Cowboys’ offensive line is already bolstered by stalwarts like Tyler Smith, a two-time Pro Bowler, and rookie Cooper Beebe, who is projected to make significant strides at center in 2025. The addition of Tyler Booker, a highly-rated interior lineman from the 2025 NFL Draft, further strengthens the unit. However, the left tackle position remains a question mark, and the competition between Guyton and Richards could define the success of Dallas’ revamped offense.
Head coach Mike McCarthy and his staff face a pivotal decision. Will they stick with Guyton, banking on his high draft pedigree and long-term potential, or will they turn to Richards, whose under-the-radar progress could lead to a breakout season? Some have even speculated about moving Tyler Smith back to left tackle if Guyton falters, though this seems unlikely given Smith’s dominance at guard.
The stakes are high for the Cowboys, who are coming off an active offseason that included a blockbuster trade for wide receiver George Pickens to pair with CeeDee Lamb, as well as significant additions to their running back room with Jaydon Blue, Javonte Williams, and Miles Sanders. A reliable left tackle is crucial to protecting quarterback Dak Prescott, who is returning from a hamstring injury that sidelined him for much of the 2024 season. The Cowboys’ aspirations for a deep playoff run in 2025 hinge on a cohesive offensive line, and the left tackle battle will be a key storyline to watch during OTAs and training camp.
As the Cowboys prepare for a high-profile season, with primetime matchups against the Kansas City Chiefs on Thanksgiving and the Philadelphia Eagles in the season opener, the left tackle decision could be the X-factor that determines whether Dallas can compete with the NFC’s elite. Will it be Guyton stepping up to fulfill his draft promise, or will Richards emerge as the surprise star no one saw coming? The answer could redefine the Cowboys’ offensive identity in 2025.