Skip to main content

The Buffalo Bills’ Running Back Curse: From LeSean McCoy to James Cook – Why Do Bills RBs Always Get Caught in Contract Drama?

The Buffalo Bills, a team with a strong presence in NFL history, have attracted attention not only for their performance on the field but also for the “dramas” surrounding their running back (RB) contracts. From LeSean McCoy to James Cook, one undeniable fact remains: the Bills’ RBs have consistently faced notable contract issues. Why is this the case? Let’s dive into the story.

LeSean McCoy – A Star Not Fully Appreciated

LeSean McCoy, one of the greatest running backs in NFL history, joined the Buffalo Bills in 2015. In the early years, McCoy showcased impressive performances, becoming a key player for the Bills. However, his contract story with the team was filled with tension. In 2017, McCoy demanded a long-term deal, but the team was not keen on extending his contract. McCoy was not only forced to play under his current contract but also faced speculation about his future with the Bills. Despite being one of the top RBs at the time, the lack of decisiveness on extending his deal created a strained atmosphere.

After McCoy left the Bills in 2019 to join the Kansas City Chiefs, the relationship between him and the team was never fully resolved. McCoy was not offered the contract extension he desired, and his departure served as a symbol of an unfinished contract story.

From LeSean McCoy to James Cook: A Continuous Drama
Since McCoy’s departure, the Bills’ running back position has been mired in similar contract issues. Recently, James Cook, one of the Bills’ promising young RBs, made headlines with his contract situation. After listing his house in Orchard Park for sale, a location where the Bills’ team is based, questions began to arise about Cook’s future with the team.

Ian Rapoport, NFL Network insider, shared in an interview that the contract negotiations with Cook weren’t going smoothly. Cook had requested a salary of $15 million, a figure that the Bills were not enthusiastic about. This made many reconsider his future with the team. While Rapoport assured that Cook would still play for the Bills next season, the contract situation was far from being resolved amicably. This once again highlights the ongoing issues with the running back position in Buffalo.

Why Does Buffalo Bills Always Face Running Back Contract Drama?

Team Strategy and the Value of Running Backs in the System

One of the main reasons Buffalo Bills face difficulties in re-signing running backs is the team’s strategy. Under the leadership of head coach Sean McDermott and general manager Brandon Beane, the Bills have focused on building a dynamic offensive system with QB Josh Allen at its core. This means that while running backs are important, they do not hold the same priority in the team’s tactical approach. With a focus on developing offensive lines and QBs, the Bills aren’t inclined to spend heavily on running backs.
Injury Risk and Instability at the Running Back Position

The running back position in the NFL is highly susceptible to injuries, and the Bills are no exception. Injuries can significantly impact a running back’s performance and their value in the market. This makes the Bills, like many other teams, hesitant to commit to long-term deals with running backs, especially when they have the option of finding replacements.

High Salary Demands from RBs

As seen in the case of James Cook, the high salary demands of running backs are a significant factor in their contract issues with the Bills. Players like Cook, with great potential and impressive performances, confidently ask for high salaries to ensure their fair compensation. However, the team often refuses such requests, leading to tense negotiations.

Team Culture and Top-Down Decisions

Finally, the culture of the team and decisions made by the front office greatly impact the contract situation for running backs. The Bills tend to make contract decisions carefully, avoiding overspending on positions that can be replaced in many cases. This leads to impatience and a lack of agreement between the players and the team.

The Future of the Running Back Position in Buffalo Bills

While the history of running back contracts with the Buffalo Bills may be full of drama, the question remains: Can the situation change in the future? With James Cook’s development and other potential candidates, could the Bills adjust their strategy and give more importance to the running back position? This is certainly a story that will continue to attract attention in the coming seasons.

Conclusion

The “running back curse” of the Bills is a complex and intriguing tale, not just because of contract issues but also due to the team’s approach to managing and developing the position. From LeSean McCoy to James Cook, each story provides insights into the strategies and decisions that NFL teams must navigate when dealing with key players. Perhaps, in the future, the Buffalo Bills will find a new way to approach this issue and resolve the ongoing contract dramas. Until then, the saga of the Bills’