Former NFL running back and current sports analyst LeSean McCoy sparked controversy this week by suggesting that rookie quarterback Joe Milton could unseat Dak Prescott as the Dallas Cowboys’ starting quarterback in 2024. During a segment on FS1’s Speak, McCoy argued that Milton’s raw talent and arm strength might compel the Cowboys to make a dramatic change under center. However, the claim has been met with widespread skepticism, with experts and fans alike questioning its validity.
McCoy’s Controversial Take
McCoy, known for his unfiltered opinions, doubled down on his stance during the show:
“Watch this: Joe Milton will be the Cowboys’ QB1 over Dak. They’re gonna realize they’ve got something special in Milton. His ceiling is higher, and that arm is unreal. Dak’s good, but this is a business. If they think Milton can do more, they’ll make the move.”
The statement immediately went viral, with critics pointing out glaring inaccuracies. Most notably, Joe Milton is not even on the Cowboys’ roster. The 24-year-old quarterback was selected by the New England Patriots in the sixth round of the 2024 NFL Draft after an up-and-down college career at Tennessee and Michigan. Milton, while possessing a cannon arm, is widely viewed as a developmental prospect who may not see the field in 2024, let alone challenge a proven starter like Prescott.
Dak Prescott’s Status in Dallas
Prescott, entering the final year of his contract, remains the undisputed QB1 in Dallas despite ongoing contract extension negotiations. The two-time Pro Bowler threw for 4,516 yards and an NFL-leading 36 touchdowns in 2023, silencing critics after a turnover-plagued 2022 season. While the Cowboys have yet to secure his long-term future, owner Jerry Jones has repeatedly expressed confidence in Prescott, calling him “our guy” as recently as June.
The idea of Dallas benching Prescott for an unproven rookie — especially one not on their roster — defies logic. The Cowboys are in “win-now” mode, with a roster built to contend for a Super Bowl. Transitioning to a project quarterback like Milton would represent a seismic shift in strategy, one the organization has given no indication of pursuing.
Where’s the Truth?
McCoy’s comments appear rooted in hyperbole rather than reality. Analysts speculate that his remarks were meant to generate debate, a common tactic in sports media. NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport quickly dismissed the claim, tweeting:
“Let’s be clear: There’s zero traction to Joe Milton replacing Dak Prescott. Milton is a Patriot. Dak is the Cowboys’ QB. LeSean is doing his job — getting people talking.”
Meanwhile, Milton himself is focused on learning behind Patriots starter Jacoby Brissett and rookie Drake Maye. New England’s coaching staff has praised his work ethic but emphasized he’ll need time to refine his mechanics and decision-making.
The Bottom Line
While McCoy’s hot take succeeded in stirring conversation, it lacks factual basis. Prescott’s role in Dallas is secure for 2024, and Milton’s path to playing time — if it exists — lies in New England. The Cowboys’ quarterback drama, if any, revolves around Prescott’s contract, not his job security. Unless a monumental trade occurs (which no credible sources have suggested), McCoy’s prediction will remain a headline-grabbing fiction.
Update: McCoy later clarified his comments on social media, writing, “I’m just saying, IF Milton was in Dallas, they’d have a tough choice. But yeah, he’s a Patriot. Let’s see how that plays out!”
For now, Cowboys fans can rest easy: Dak Prescott remains the face of the franchise, and Joe Milton’s arm is New England’s project to develop.